Daas Torah - Issues of Jewish Identity: Sheldon Silver, New York

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Sunday, 12 October 2014

Beis Din - Authority comes from being agents of Israeli beis din which had semicha - how does that work?

Posted on 01:25 by viju
Tur (Choshen Mishpat 1): Today, when there is no ordination, all the judges are unqualified according to the Torah, as it is written, “before them,” [Exodus 21:1] meaning before ’elohim, as written in the pericope, which is to say ordained [judges], and we interpret that to mean “before them and not before laymen,” and we ourselves are laymen [in that sense]. Therefore there are no judges with authority from the Torah except if they act as the agents [of the ordained judges of Palestine].

Prof Radzyner has a very interesting article on the authority of the contemporary beis din [click link]
Abstract: A sugya just a few lines long in the Babylonian Talmud, Gittin 88b, had enormous influence on the development of Jewish law in the area of the authority to pass judgment given to rabbinical courts in our day. According to the simple, commonly accepted understanding of this sugya, the Tannaim ruled that the Torah forbade men who had not received ordination to act as judges, and as a result, the judges in Babylonia were permitted to adjudicate, of necessity, only as agents of the judges of Palestine we act as their agents). The article reexamines these positions. The first part suggests two new ways to understand the essence of the agency of which R. Joseph spoke in the sugya. The second part of the article reexamines the source of the prohibition, to the extent that it exists, against adjudication by laymen
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Schlesinger Twins: Sarah's guest post regarding Rabbi Biderman
    Sarah promised to discuss the Schlesinger Twins case with Rabbi Biderman if I posted his written testimony to the  court from 2012. I have...
  • Lonna Kin Divorce: Unwilling to Allow His Wife a Divorce, He Marries Another
    NY Times    The wedding was a modest affair, held in a reception hall overlooking an artificial lake tucked behind a suburban strip. But ju...
  • Schlesinger twins: Beth discusses the issue of psychological assessments typically required in custody cases
    Rabbi Tzadok has raised some important questions regarding this custody case. I asked Beth Alexander to respond to his questions as well as ...
  • תדהמה בלייקווד: הרב הבכיר יילך לכלא
    bhol תדהמה בלייקווד: הרב פישל טוד, הממונה על הרבנים הצבאיים בצבא ארה"ב, ומבכירי העסקנים ובעלי החסד בלייקווד, נידון בבית המשפט הפדראלי ...
  • The Million Jew Seder By Rabbi Shmully Hecht
    The article below says some important things that need to be said and acted upon. After I read it I spoke with Rabbi Hecht and asked him to ...
  • Tamar Epstein is free according to the Kaminetsky's - how they explained it.
    ORA has suddenly proclaimed that Tamara Epstein - after a number of years as an "aguna" because her husband would not give her a g...
  • Rivky Stein & Yoel Weiss: Yoel's version posted on Rivky website
    This was previous published in the first post on this topic. However I was asked to make a separate post for easy reference. Yoel Weiss view...
  • Siruv against Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Kaufman by Beis Din Givas Hamorah
    See previous post  See post regarding siruv issued by Rabbi Kaufman
  • Rifky Stein & Yoel Weiss: Israel Farkash - "coordinator" of Mill Basin Beis Din - breaking news
    Allegations have been made that the court records are referring to Israel Farkash of the Beis Din. Arrested September 15 for an incident on ...
  • 15 Are Charged With Defrauding Banks and Other Lenders of $20 Million
    F.B.I. Press release Preet Bharara, the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, and George Venizelos, the Assistant D...

Blog Archive

  • ►  2015 (31)
    • ►  January (31)
  • ▼  2014 (469)
    • ►  December (41)
    • ►  November (55)
    • ▼  October (44)
      • The Danger of Science Denial
      • Distinction between social judgment and judgment o...
      • Schlesinger Twins: Michael lies to court that Beth...
      • Rav Shmuel Kaminetsky claims that vaccinations are...
      • R Freundel accused of Mikve camera: Police set up ...
      • Each life is precious: The life of children with s...
      • Observations about the Salk Polio vaccine - Nation...
      • Polygamist cult leader Goel Ratzon sentenced to 30...
      • Karen Mosquera hy"d - second victim of Hamas terro...
      • Top Cop's Housemaid Admits She Made Up Affair - ac...
      • Today: Satmar Hasidic Men's-Mikva sexually abused ...
      • The Shabbos Project: New Versus the Old -- Questio...
      • Working women - Orthodox feminism or simply facing...
      • Iran to execute woman accused of killing attempted...
      • Rabbi Barry Freundel - prominent Modern Orthodox ...
      • Rumors change a person's status- sources
      • Still having problems with Disqus? - some solutions
      • "The Shabbos Project" - Problems which cannot be ...
      • What if Age Is Nothing but a Mind-Set? The conscio...
      • Terror Attack in Jerusalem - Hamas says it is natu...
      • Allan Katz - Shemittah and meeting your kids' nutr...
      • IDF Finally Admits: Hamas Planned Terror-Tunnel Ma...
      • Joey (Deutsch) Diangello - courageous advocate aga...
      • Should sexual abuse be accepted as an inherent par...
      • The "scientific" claim that Jack the Ripper was de...
      • Rav Schochet - prominent Chabad rabbi - bans Telus...
      • New book reveals that Eichman was truly evil - not...
      • Former student confronts her alleged abuser – a tr...
      • My father, locked in his body but soaring free
      • The Beggars of Lakewood - New York Times
      • Sleep deprivation prevents removal of toxic waste ...
      • Conservative rabbi is supported by congregation af...
      • Philosophers Debating G-d from NY Times blog
      • Rav Triebitz:Chol HaMoed Sukkos - What is Beis Din?
      • Problem with the Theory of Evolution or "Pay no at...
      • Beis Din - Authority comes from being agents of Is...
      • Succoth , She'mimi A'tzeret 74 - Futuristic Happiness
      • Rabbi Yakov Horowitz's asks parents to speak to th...
      • D.A. Kenneth Thompson failed to keep his promise t...
      • Evolution and Religion - an update by an evolution...
      • Absurd Mandatory sentences: Killing in self-defens...
      • Yom HaDin - a reminder of the inherent insecurity ...
      • Another "cool" charismatic teacher arrested for a...
      • Emancipation and individual freedom - destroyed th...
    • ►  September (37)
    • ►  August (67)
    • ►  July (63)
    • ►  June (39)
    • ►  May (40)
    • ►  April (38)
    • ►  March (45)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

viju
View my complete profile